Saturday, December 10, 2005

The big get bigger.

I'm still figuring out what I think of the whole "Yahoo Acquires del.icio.us" thing. It's the latest piece of news to get the people with blogs all a twitter - that and some silly flairup between people at "Les Blogs" in Paris. I have a bad habit of immediately reading about such things on Rich's blog and of course commenting on his blog instead of my own - sorry Rich, you know I'm trying to stop doing that, honest!
So the big get bigger, and the rich get richer. I've read some good analysis from folks - including the ever wise Dan, something a little different from Trebor, and of course a prophetic lesson on what's happenned before from David. I'm probably in closest agreement to Trebor's point of view - kind of a disgusted resigned feeling of sadness (not to put words in Trebor's mouth - just speaking for myself here). I know this is how the world works (with twitters on Technorati - if that's a bang or a whimper, well, you decide) but I still don't like it. I don't like it when the Fortune 500 do it, and I don't like it when megacorporations in my industry do it either. The antiglobalization movement has made valid points on how corporations work; corporations in the technology sector should not be exempt from that analysis as well.

I don't expect the technology business sector (open 2.0 technologies or not) to operate in a bubble away from other industries, but every time a large corporation like Yahoo buys out a smaller company that's created a great tool that people love and feel ownership of, well, it makes me feel like nothing's changed - that it's all just business, money and acquisition, and has nothing to do with using technology to solve a problem. I feel the same way about Google doing it - I feel the same way when any company does it. Innovation comes from creating a solution that fulfill's a user/customer/person's need; acquisition of a company that makes a tool is not a substitute for making better products. If I at least bought into the branding myth of Yahoo, if I at least felt like they cared about me as a user, that I wasn't just a nameless schlub with a ID, well, perhaps this would sit well with me. But that's all I am. A Yahoo ID to them.

Here's a lesson in branding. My allegiance to the Apple brand is simple, really - they create a product that doesn't make me sick to my stomach to use - that it's about creating an insanely great product superior to what's created by Microsoft. It has nothing to do with which company they've bought out - if Apple's bought anyone out in the name of 'innovating', please educate me if I'm wrong here. It's not about creating a 360 portal or city wide Wifi - it's just about creating something that works well, that keeps people happy, that fulfills a need and does it well. I don't see many large corporations doing that, because I suppose that's not what they're there for or how they operate. Sure, I'll continue to use del.icio.us - for now - and yes, I'll use Yahoo Groups because everyone still does so - just don't expect me to feel much good from them, their way of business, or their ultimate plans. Yes, my analysis at this point is naive and simplistic, but I'm frustrated - frustrated that this tired old paradigm of acquisition rather than development. In the end I suppose it all works out, but it doesn't stop me from having a sinking feeling in the pit of my stomach - that whoever dies with the most toys has won.

There's got to be some other way. I don't expect socialism in this industry, but I do expect something other than the 20th century paradigm of smaller fish getting eaten up by bigger fish. I don't think any of these larger tech companies are necessarily entirely Evil with a Capital E, but you can forgive me if I'm a little suspicious of companies when their actions look more like a giant game of chess (Rushing towards the checkmate of beating Microsoft and Google) than creating great products. I'm tired of the old ways the world has worked - surely to God there's got to be a better way...

2 comments:

  1. I agree in principle--I hate it when a local shop or restaurant closes because the Walmart or Bennigan's comes to town.
    Yet I also put myself in the place of the folks working for Blogger (!) or Delicious or whoever--faced with an offer for megamillions, who wouldn't take the offer? Too, often the folks who create the companies that get sold turn around & create others....we hope.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Joe,

    yes, on a micro level I can understand someone's motivation for taking a big paycheque/buy out for their service; me, I'm always looking at the macro level, though, which wonders if acquisition of a smaller company is seen as a replacement for innovating from within a company. Maybe if Yahoo had done this 2 years ago - instead, it's now, and it can look like they're doing such things to strike while the 2.0 iron is hot, as it were.

    I'm sure it will turn out ok for the users of Yahoo, but it all still makes me a bit queasy. I'm sure that will pass with time, and turn into resignation...

    ReplyDelete