"It’s all these Flickr-wannabes, flip-it-quick companies that are bugging me. ..." - so says Russell Beattie in his blog. Goddamn, if his words - and the categorization of the companies! - aren't golden and great to read, as well as being very, very funny. Nice to see another cynic - and I mean that in the best possible way, too - weighing in. Good stuff.
Thursday, October 27, 2005
A short letter
Dear ISP,
I love you, you're great and everything - very reliable, reasonable, good customer service, great name and all that - but really, did you have to have problems with my webmail today just when I was sending a resume out? Impecable timing - I'll give you that...
Signed,
About to open a support ticket, but rants don't fit in that character limited space...
I love you, you're great and everything - very reliable, reasonable, good customer service, great name and all that - but really, did you have to have problems with my webmail today just when I was sending a resume out? Impecable timing - I'll give you that...
Signed,
About to open a support ticket, but rants don't fit in that character limited space...
Wednesday, October 26, 2005
Welcome to x - you might like to try y while you're here.
Ok, another one of those crazy ideas which one posts obsessively to one's blog.
While checking out a fellow Canadian's various online sites, I found that he had categorized their commentary on photos the same way as I tend to think about geographic areas - that place x was the equivalent of place y. Looking at Tony's picture, I read the caption - "UBC's equivalent of the SLC" and the picture - a lounge area. I can put two and two together and say
We need a site that facilitates those types of experiences for people, to allow them to link up that new place with the person's pre-existing information. It's not an Amazonian recommendation service exactly, but it's a variant of it... a geographic recommendation tool, if you will.
Here's an example: arriving from one gloriously big city to another gloriously big city, you want to find out where the neighbourhoods to visit and get to know are located. If somebody says, "oh, it's in the Mission", I know what they're saying - 'the Mission' is a metaphorical shorthand for 'funky neighbourhood with lots of neat shops and an interesting cultural environment'. But I'm not going to know it's a funky neighbourhood unless I either visit there, or have a recommendation to visit there (from someone, a web site, a travel book, whatever). Ah, but if someone from Toronto said to me, "The Mission is a lot like College Street just east of Little Italy", I instantly know what I'm getting at.
This kind of site would be linking up people's mental models for better information processing and understanding. You obviously don't want to stereotype any neighbourhoods - people of Jane & Finch in Toronto, and Hell's Kitchen in NYC, I feel your pain. The idea is to engadge people's understanding of what they know, and extend it to what they don't. I'd like to find the equivalent of Toronto's eye newspaper, its so-so alternative radio station (CFNY), its fancy Park-Avenue type stores (so I can avoid them) and so many more things. I like finding them out through adventure and exploring, but if there's a web site that the next time I visit Washington DC to try out Adams Morgan if I'm looking for funky coffee shops, well, wouldn't that make one's life that much easier?
So many things make up our cumulative experiences as citizens, as consumers, as people. The trick always comes around to finding the information, and linking it up. That's the task not only of information architects, but of all of us. Perhaps some sort of neighbourhood encyclopedia linking site could work towards that. I was lucky enough to grow up in Toronto's Annex - those who've visited it or who know of it know exactly why I loved it, or why I would like it. A small stretch of Bloor Street between Spadina and Bathurst, it was a lovely stomping ground with its share of funky stores, lovely coffee shops and pubs, and an aura that gave it meaning to its residents. I'm not so pathetic as to look for an Annex in every city I meet, but somedays, on a day when you're missing your hometown, well, when someone's looking for Kilgour's Bar Meets Grill and the friendly bartender that goes with it, well, nothing else will do.
While checking out a fellow Canadian's various online sites, I found that he had categorized their commentary on photos the same way as I tend to think about geographic areas - that place x was the equivalent of place y. Looking at Tony's picture, I read the caption - "UBC's equivalent of the SLC" and the picture - a lounge area. I can put two and two together and say
- UBC is the University of British Columbia - a place that Tony was probably visiting
- SLC is probably some Student Learning - or Lounging? - Center - from his wording of it, Tony had a SLC in the university he was at (University of Waterloo).
- I understand instinctively what a SLC is as well because I can also add my own equivalent SLC and say Innis College at the University of Toronto had an equivalent (the Pit? the Hub? Something equally annoying early 90sname).
We need a site that facilitates those types of experiences for people, to allow them to link up that new place with the person's pre-existing information. It's not an Amazonian recommendation service exactly, but it's a variant of it... a geographic recommendation tool, if you will.
Here's an example: arriving from one gloriously big city to another gloriously big city, you want to find out where the neighbourhoods to visit and get to know are located. If somebody says, "oh, it's in the Mission", I know what they're saying - 'the Mission' is a metaphorical shorthand for 'funky neighbourhood with lots of neat shops and an interesting cultural environment'. But I'm not going to know it's a funky neighbourhood unless I either visit there, or have a recommendation to visit there (from someone, a web site, a travel book, whatever). Ah, but if someone from Toronto said to me, "The Mission is a lot like College Street just east of Little Italy", I instantly know what I'm getting at.
This kind of site would be linking up people's mental models for better information processing and understanding. You obviously don't want to stereotype any neighbourhoods - people of Jane & Finch in Toronto, and Hell's Kitchen in NYC, I feel your pain. The idea is to engadge people's understanding of what they know, and extend it to what they don't. I'd like to find the equivalent of Toronto's eye newspaper, its so-so alternative radio station (CFNY), its fancy Park-Avenue type stores (so I can avoid them) and so many more things. I like finding them out through adventure and exploring, but if there's a web site that the next time I visit Washington DC to try out Adams Morgan if I'm looking for funky coffee shops, well, wouldn't that make one's life that much easier?
So many things make up our cumulative experiences as citizens, as consumers, as people. The trick always comes around to finding the information, and linking it up. That's the task not only of information architects, but of all of us. Perhaps some sort of neighbourhood encyclopedia linking site could work towards that. I was lucky enough to grow up in Toronto's Annex - those who've visited it or who know of it know exactly why I loved it, or why I would like it. A small stretch of Bloor Street between Spadina and Bathurst, it was a lovely stomping ground with its share of funky stores, lovely coffee shops and pubs, and an aura that gave it meaning to its residents. I'm not so pathetic as to look for an Annex in every city I meet, but somedays, on a day when you're missing your hometown, well, when someone's looking for Kilgour's Bar Meets Grill and the friendly bartender that goes with it, well, nothing else will do.
Tuesday, October 25, 2005
About that ad...
What prompted the previous entry was a look at the brochure for the studio tours offered as part of DUX2005, a conference I'm attending the first week of November. It's a PDF with information on the design studios that are openning their doors for a day. A nice enough document, but missing some of the information design elements that make life easier - like, oh, perhaps a map with the actual studios listed on the same page? Or perhaps a matrix listing who does what - which firms specialize in which disciplines, products, size of company, etc. etc.)
But maybe it's not up to a conference site to do it. A conference is basically a well-orchestrated flash mob; to get to real change one has to actually do it outside of any one event. I'm looking for a site that shows the User Experience Design industry is organized and a force to contend with. A site that says, "we are your product designers (be they web sites, actual physical products". This is what we do. This is who we are. This is why you're going to need us or you'll fail.
If someone knows of such a site, please do let me know. I hate to go on a condemnation rant without just cause. I know at least the User Experience Network and AIGA are out there, and these organizations are a step in the right direction. It's at the practitioner level, though - where are the companies that do this professionally? Or do members of a community only talk to each other at individual conferences, belong to their individual associations, and stay in their siloed little worlds?
There are piles of words that can - and should - be written about making user experience a necessary player in the rest of the business world. At some point could someone put down the need to write words and actually organize a group to link organizations and people? Otherwise the words are just words of meaning, and not words of action.
But maybe it's not up to a conference site to do it. A conference is basically a well-orchestrated flash mob; to get to real change one has to actually do it outside of any one event. I'm looking for a site that shows the User Experience Design industry is organized and a force to contend with. A site that says, "we are your product designers (be they web sites, actual physical products". This is what we do. This is who we are. This is why you're going to need us or you'll fail.
If someone knows of such a site, please do let me know. I hate to go on a condemnation rant without just cause. I know at least the User Experience Network and AIGA are out there, and these organizations are a step in the right direction. It's at the practitioner level, though - where are the companies that do this professionally? Or do members of a community only talk to each other at individual conferences, belong to their individual associations, and stay in their siloed little worlds?
There are piles of words that can - and should - be written about making user experience a necessary player in the rest of the business world. At some point could someone put down the need to write words and actually organize a group to link organizations and people? Otherwise the words are just words of meaning, and not words of action.
A Personal Ad with a Personal Plea.
Wanted:
SWF, 31, seeks WWW (URL) for mutually convenient relationship. WWW must be a site listing design studios (international too - I like to travel), what their specialities are (interaction design? information design? information architecture? product design? industrial design? etc.) and other salient factors in matching a prospective job candidate (methodologies, products, culture, management structure, etc.). I'm ideally looking for a site that has an organnization behind it - you know, a WWW had a good URL like ads.org which represents the Association of Design Studios. What, one doesn't exist? What a pity - no wonder user experience doesn't have as much value as it should. We don't play like the business world, so we don't get input when we should.
Anyway, these ads only have so many spaces, so I'll wrap it up. My likes: passionate user advocacy, good methodologies, interdisciplinary teams solving problems, clear marketing language on a web site that doesn't make me want to retch, and many others.
Reply to info@rachelmmurray.com. Your pic of a studio gets my pic of a portfolio.
SWF, 31, seeks WWW (URL) for mutually convenient relationship. WWW must be a site listing design studios (international too - I like to travel), what their specialities are (interaction design? information design? information architecture? product design? industrial design? etc.) and other salient factors in matching a prospective job candidate (methodologies, products, culture, management structure, etc.). I'm ideally looking for a site that has an organnization behind it - you know, a WWW had a good URL like ads.org which represents the Association of Design Studios. What, one doesn't exist? What a pity - no wonder user experience doesn't have as much value as it should. We don't play like the business world, so we don't get input when we should.
Anyway, these ads only have so many spaces, so I'll wrap it up. My likes: passionate user advocacy, good methodologies, interdisciplinary teams solving problems, clear marketing language on a web site that doesn't make me want to retch, and many others.
Reply to info@rachelmmurray.com. Your pic of a studio gets my pic of a portfolio.
Sunday, October 23, 2005
Someone with critical analysis - quick, he must be shot!
Flippant title aside, time to plug one of my favourite blogs of all time - Rich over at basement.org. He's hit it out of the ballpark again, this time with a good analysis of what happens to products when they're created but the hype becomes more of a distraction than anything (a.k.a. Flock). I've posted some comments on his entry, which you can read over there.
Ever have that happen - you comment on someone's blog and then something goes wrong (the post shows up three times), and you're left embarassed and wondering why you bother commenting in the first place - or is that just me? Anyway, in these times where the Web 2.0 hype has overtaken many people's ability to critically analyze products, innovation and business, it's nice to have a few lone voices in the wilderness to keep people on track, to hold their feet to the flame when necessary, and to bring the products and business back to where it matters - the users. He should have a spot over on the O'Reilly Network or some such place of influence. I don't know what site all the 'influential bloggers' post at, so forgive me Rich if I've placed you in with some iffy company. I've saved about 20 of his posts because time and again he's saying what needs to be said. As I mentioned in the comments on his site, it's a shame he's over on the East Coast, because there are folks out West here who would benefit to listenning to his thoughts before they rush to create another 2.0 technology, pitch a product that doesn't have a need or create something new in a field where the established products already work.
Perhaps I'm being harsh on Flock - I don't mean to be. I'm sure they're all good folks, with their hearts in the right place. And it's certainly not their fault that among the Digerati that 2.0 hype is starting to bubble over the caldron it was created in, taking down anything in its path. I'm just finding it hard to find discriminating intelligent opinion on Web 2.0 related hype amidst all the product launches, the sycophantic plugin and backscratching and all the in-fighting.
Take the latest batch of bickering on one of my professional-related mailing lists - and no, it's not the one you think of. There are factions and arguments that would add many a good entry to the Flame Warriors page. I need a freakin' score card just to keep track of who thinks what about whom, who to listen to, who to disregard, and oh so importantly, who invented what term/technology/product and when. At some point it becomes mindnumbingly exhausting, but I suppose it's inevitable when you get a bunch of intelligent people sharing a conversation over a text-based medium.
And that, in the end is what brings it back to that 2.0 hype - it's a lot of sound and fury, signifying nothing, isn't it? It's exhilarating when you attend a conference and feel like you're surfing on a hide wave of Innovative Technology; when you realize that it may not amount to a hill of beans in the end if most people won't use it because they can't or they don't hear of these things in the first place, well, then you come crashing back to earth and it ain't pretty. So thank you Rich... we do need more people like you willing to step back and ask what the value of all of it is. When the product launches are over, the schwag has been handed out, the 'blogosphere' has moved onto another topic to gossip over, and the inevitable post-2.0 bubble burst has occured, at least Rich can take comfort in the fact he was right on so many fronts. It may be cold comfort, but at least it's not the false and ultimately empty comfort of overhype.
Ever have that happen - you comment on someone's blog and then something goes wrong (the post shows up three times), and you're left embarassed and wondering why you bother commenting in the first place - or is that just me? Anyway, in these times where the Web 2.0 hype has overtaken many people's ability to critically analyze products, innovation and business, it's nice to have a few lone voices in the wilderness to keep people on track, to hold their feet to the flame when necessary, and to bring the products and business back to where it matters - the users. He should have a spot over on the O'Reilly Network or some such place of influence. I don't know what site all the 'influential bloggers' post at, so forgive me Rich if I've placed you in with some iffy company. I've saved about 20 of his posts because time and again he's saying what needs to be said. As I mentioned in the comments on his site, it's a shame he's over on the East Coast, because there are folks out West here who would benefit to listenning to his thoughts before they rush to create another 2.0 technology, pitch a product that doesn't have a need or create something new in a field where the established products already work.
Perhaps I'm being harsh on Flock - I don't mean to be. I'm sure they're all good folks, with their hearts in the right place. And it's certainly not their fault that among the Digerati that 2.0 hype is starting to bubble over the caldron it was created in, taking down anything in its path. I'm just finding it hard to find discriminating intelligent opinion on Web 2.0 related hype amidst all the product launches, the sycophantic plugin and backscratching and all the in-fighting.
Take the latest batch of bickering on one of my professional-related mailing lists - and no, it's not the one you think of. There are factions and arguments that would add many a good entry to the Flame Warriors page. I need a freakin' score card just to keep track of who thinks what about whom, who to listen to, who to disregard, and oh so importantly, who invented what term/technology/product and when. At some point it becomes mindnumbingly exhausting, but I suppose it's inevitable when you get a bunch of intelligent people sharing a conversation over a text-based medium.
And that, in the end is what brings it back to that 2.0 hype - it's a lot of sound and fury, signifying nothing, isn't it? It's exhilarating when you attend a conference and feel like you're surfing on a hide wave of Innovative Technology; when you realize that it may not amount to a hill of beans in the end if most people won't use it because they can't or they don't hear of these things in the first place, well, then you come crashing back to earth and it ain't pretty. So thank you Rich... we do need more people like you willing to step back and ask what the value of all of it is. When the product launches are over, the schwag has been handed out, the 'blogosphere' has moved onto another topic to gossip over, and the inevitable post-2.0 bubble burst has occured, at least Rich can take comfort in the fact he was right on so many fronts. It may be cold comfort, but at least it's not the false and ultimately empty comfort of overhype.
Saturday, October 22, 2005
British wit is a beautiful thing
gapingvoid: gravestone
HAHAHA!!!
I came across Hugh Macleod's business card art a whle back, but since then he's got a store where you can actually buy the things. He's got a great British dry wit, and he's spot on about all of the trends in the technology, marketing and general zeitgeist of this crazy culture that is Life, 2005. If you must know I'm having the damnest time trying to decide which of the 56 designs to choose from. Just too many classic ones to choose from. Highly recommended.
Found via the lovely Tara's blog, HorsePigCow
HAHAHA!!!
I came across Hugh Macleod's business card art a whle back, but since then he's got a store where you can actually buy the things. He's got a great British dry wit, and he's spot on about all of the trends in the technology, marketing and general zeitgeist of this crazy culture that is Life, 2005. If you must know I'm having the damnest time trying to decide which of the 56 designs to choose from. Just too many classic ones to choose from. Highly recommended.
Found via the lovely Tara's blog, HorsePigCow
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)